How to Make a Concrete Candle Holder in a Plastic Bucket

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read the full disclosure.

Pressing an empty plastic cup into wet cement works for about ten seconds, and then it floats back up. A river stone about the size of a grapefruit, set on top, keeps it down.

You’ll also love: How to Make a Carved Concrete Planter from a Plastic Crate, How to Make Concrete Mushroom Garden Stakes in Eggshells, How to Make a River Rock Concrete Planter from a Milk Crate.

Our concrete candle holder is quick-setting cement poured into a quart plastic deli container, with a 2-ounce cup pressed in to make the candle well. It comes out a 4½-inch cylinder weighing about 6 pounds.

The first pour went into an unoiled container, and it took a pair of scissors to get the cement back out.

Pulling the cup gives a small suction pop. A friend asked if we’d bought it at a home store, then wanted to know why it had tiny holes on the side.

Gray concrete candle holder with a lit white candle in warm light

Project at a glance

Active time
About 30 minutes
Cure time
1 day to demold, 2 before use
Cost
About $40 for two
Difficulty
Easy
Finished size
4½ in across, 5 in tall

Why a Stone Sits on the Cup

A hollow cup pushed into wet cement is a little boat, and the cement pushes it up with about a third of a pound of force. Anything heavier on top holds it level until the cement sets, 15 to 30 minutes later.

We expected tapping to get rid of every bubble. Most went; the ones that stayed left pinholes on the side, which read as texture more than flaws.

The finished well is about 1¾ inches across, a snug fit for a tealight.

Materials & Tools

Quick-setting cement1 pail, 10 lb — enough for two holders
Plastic deli containers, 32 oz1 pack — one per holder
Check on Amazon
Plastic shot cups, 2 oz1 pack — one per candle well
Check on Amazon
River stone, about 1 lb1 — the weight on the cup
Cooking spray1 can — the release
Candle adhesive putty1 pack — holds a taper upright in the well
Check on Amazon
Felt pads and 120-grit sandpaper1 sheet, 1 small pack
Check on Amazon
Disposable gloves1 pair — cement burns skin
Check on Amazon

Not in the $40: the candles and the gloves.

Tealight or taper: a 1½-inch tealight drops straight into the well. A taper is about ⅞ inch at the base and needs a ring of candle putty to stand straight.

Two at once: one 10-pound pail fills two quart containers with a little left over, so mix for both in one batch.

Same idea, bigger: a bucket and a ball shape a sink the same way the container and cup shape this, as in our concrete outdoor sink.

Watch the Build

Step by Step

Step 1Oil the molds

Spray the inside of the deli container and the outside of the shot cup with a light, even coat of cooking spray. Wipe off any puddles; they leave smooth bald spots on the surface.

Thin deli containers flex, which is why they let go. A glass jar or a metal can won’t.

Two clear plastic containers on a marble table ready for the concrete candle holder pour

Step 2Mix and pour

Stir 1 part water into 5 parts cement by volume, the ratio on Quikrete’s data sheet, until it pours like thick pancake batter; measure the water with the same cup you use for the powder. Pour it into the container to about half an inch from the top.

Work steadily; it starts to stiffen in about 10 minutes. Gloves on, since wet cement burns skin.

Pouring gray cement from one plastic container into the oiled mold

Step 3Tap out the bubbles

Tap the container on the table for a full minute and watch the bubbles rise and pop. Stop when the surface stays still.

Rap the sides with a spoon handle too; the bubbles that would show are the ones against the wall.

Plastic container filled with wet cement on the table

Step 4Press in the cup

Hold the shot cup upside down over the center and push it straight down until its base sits level with the cement surface, about 1½ inches deep. Check it from two sides before letting go.

If cement creeps over the cup’s base, wipe it off with a fingertip so the well stays open.

Pressing an upside-down plastic cup into the center of the wet cement

Step 5Weigh it down

Set the river stone on the cup, cover it with a bag and leave it alone for a day. The container turns warm as the cement sets, which is normal for quick-setting cement.

River stone resting on the cup to hold it down in the setting cement

Step 6Demold

Squeeze the sides of the container to break the seal and lift it straight up. If it won’t let go, cut it off with scissors; the container is cheaper than the holder.

Work over a folded towel. A 6-pound cylinder rolling off the table chips at the rim.

Lifting the plastic container off the cured cement cylinder

Step 7Pull the cup and finish

Twist the cup out of the well. Sand the bottom edge with 120-grit, stick felt pads underneath so it won’t scratch a tabletop, and keep it damp under a bag one more day before it goes outside.

A tealight sits flush in the well; a taper gets a pea-size ring of putty around its base first.

Pulling the plastic insert out of the concrete candle holder to open the candle well

Step 8Seal it

After a week, brush a coat of water-based concrete sealer over the top and down into the well. Wax drips and soot wipe off a sealed surface; on bare cement they soak in.

Finished gray concrete cylinder with an open candle well on a marble table

How a Concrete Candle Holder Holds Up

Wax drips are the only wear. They pop off cleanly once the wax is cold, or soften with a hair dryer and wipe away. A chip at the rim sands smooth with the same 120-grit.

Left outside, it darkens with rain and dries back lighter, and the color evens out over a season.

FAQ

The cup came out crooked

It tipped before the cement set, usually because the stone sat off center. Set the stone squarely on the base of the cup next time, or tape two craft sticks across the container to hold the cup upright.

The surface is covered in pinholes

Those are air bubbles. Tap longer, or mix a little wetter; for a smoother face, brush a thin cement slurry over it and let it cure a day.

Can I use regular concrete mix?

The gravel in it is nearly as big as the wall around the well is thick. Use quick-setting cement or a sand mix with no gravel.

Is it safe to burn candles in it?

Concrete won’t burn, and the 6-pound weight keeps it from tipping. Treat it like any candle holder and never leave a flame burning alone.

Can I color it?

Every holder in the photos is the cement’s own plain gray. We haven’t tried a tinted batch in these, so we can’t say how quick-setting cement takes color.

The scissor-cut container from the first pour holds the craft sticks now.

The second holder, the one with more pinholes, ended up on the porch, where nobody looks that closely.

You Might Also Love

Owen Carter

I write the guides on Canonigos. Every project comes with its video, a materials list and the measurements you need to build it yourself.

Leave a Comment